Obama photo in every school? City portrait proposal stirs debate over setting precedent

Obama photo in every school? City portrait proposal stirs debate over setting precedent

Juandiego Wade

» 75 Comments | Post a Comment

A member of the Charlottesville School Board is proposing that a framed picture of President Barack Obama be placed in all of the city’s public schools, as well as the division’s central office.

None of Juandiego Wade’s colleagues was quick to jump on board with his proposal at Thursday’s meeting, nor did any members dismiss it.

Wade insisted that if the proposal were approved, he’d raise the money for the pictures and frames — which he believes can be obtained for free or very little money — through a private fundraising campaign.

“It would be no cost to the school system,” Wade said after the meeting, noting that Obama is an inspirational figure to students and faculty.

Board Chairman Ned Michie echoed thenotion that, “there’s no question that he’s an inspiring [person],” adding, however, that if a picture were hung of Obama, the same honor would have to be given to future presidents.

School Board member Colette Blount shared the sentiment.

“I think it sets a precedent,” Blount said.

The board agreed to further discuss the proposal at a later date.

Board members also expressed interest in raising money to install a synthetic turf field at Charlottesville High School, though members said they would need more data, including information about the safety of turf and maintenance costs. Members asked that school officials try to arrange a meeting between the School Board and the Charlottesville City Council to discuss the matter in October.

A turf field has been installed at Monticello High School in Albemarle County, and Western Albemarle and Albemarle high schools are still raising money to install fields.

A private donor has agreed to donate $325,000 to each of Albemarle’s three high schools and CHS, toward the $600,000 cost of installing a field.

The following is excerpted from an interview with Wade following Thursday’s meeting regarding his Obama proposal:

Q. How did you come up with this idea?

A. “It’s just something I’ve been thinking about for a while … I just think it’s going to be very inspiring for the students, visitors and teachers. And I know that there’s a lot of people in this community that we could put up there, but I just think that President Obama is the most recognizable.”

Q. Does this show favoritism toward Obama over other presidents?

A. “Well, he’s the only one right now, and [his election is historical]. So, yes, I think it is different, and if we go with this it sounds like it may be where we have to use all presidents. We make policy every day. A School Board 20 years from now may decide that we don’t want to do this anymore.”

Q. [Are some folks] going to say, “Well, why wasn’t this honor given to President Bush?”

A. “Again, I said that the election of President Obama was historical. He was the first African American. His upbringing is inspiring, and so it is different from past Democrat and Republican presidents. I know that some people will say that it’s partisan or whatever, but it’s what I want to propose and we’ll just have to see what the other board members have to say about it.”

Q. If you’re still a School Board member in 2012 and a Republican gets elected to office would you then say … “Let’s put up a picture of that president?”

A. If we are going with the policy that some board members have mentioned today, than we will, but I can’t make a statement on that, because I have no idea who’s going to be president at that point. But I think the American people are pretty good at selecting who they want to lead the country, whether that’s Republican or Democrat or independent.”

Advertisement

 
View More: No tags are associated with this article
Not what you're looking for? Try our quick search:
 

Advertisement

Reader Reactions

Flag Comment Posted by Consider this on August 07, 2009 at 9:02 am

I traveled to Cuba frequently for 6 years as a part of a former job. It strikes me as ironic that some would want Obama’s picture posted everywhere. Riding through Havana and across that beautiful country one could not miss the images of Fidel and Che Guevara. Revolutionary propaganda.

Flag Comment Posted by Cliff on August 07, 2009 at 8:29 am

To the three previous posters…....
Amen! Amen1 and Amen!

Flag Comment Posted by dillonf on August 07, 2009 at 7:54 am

Public schools are not a place for political or religious statements.  They are a place for learning and academic pursuits.  A place for non-partison consideration, leaving decisions to students as they grow and learn. 

Bias in any form is dangerous…a slippery slope, if you will.  Unless we have money to feature all the Presidents portraits, we should feature none.

Flag Comment Posted by JMM99 on August 07, 2009 at 6:45 am

I think that is a great idea and a start.  We should then look into posting his photo on the sides of buildings and banners.  I always wanted to live in a country that has all the outward appearance of a dictatorship.

I know its hard for some to believe but political leaders are not what makes America great, its the people themselves.  We’d be better off if there was not government intervention in every aspect of our life.  This idea is just one more example of that.

Flag Comment Posted by Ghost on August 07, 2009 at 6:24 am

Jesus is an inspiration to many students in the Charlottesville schools, but we don’t allow pictures of him on the walls of its classrooms.  And even if some think the President is the Second Coming, the 14th Amendment made the First Amendment applicable to the states in 1868.  The cost is not the issue, here.  It is the subtle political message inherent in the proposal that has no place in our classrooms.

Post a Comment(Requires free registration)

The commenting period has ended or commenting has been deactivated for this article.
 

Advertisement

Advertisement

Online Features
Blogs
DataCenter
Special Reports
Restaurant Guide
Movie Times
 
Video
Breaking News

Advertisement